Hledat v komentářích
Investiční doporučení
Výsledky společností - ČR
Výsledky společností - Svět
IPO, M&A
Týdenní přehledy
 

Detail - články
Have you lent someone money? If so, be wary of the due date. Based on a Supreme Court ruling, this may not be what it seems

Have you lent someone money? If so, be wary of the due date. Based on a Supreme Court ruling, this may not be what it seems

17.4.2012 14:16
Autor: Richard Hamran, KSB

The lender’s apparent upper hand in the lender-borrower relationship conceals unexpected pitfalls following a Supreme Court ruling.

Imagine that you enter into a loan agreement under which the borrower agrees to repay the loan on demand. A year or two passes and, because you do not for the moment need the money back, you wait and do not call the loan in. You believe that the statutory limitation period is on your side and cannot start to run before the due date of the loan, which is the moment when you demand repayment. You do not worry that time is passing. Big mistake. You may not have the chance to get your money back once three years has elapsed from the time when the loan was granted.

The catch is the three-year limitation period

It is wrong to believe that the statutory limitation period begins on the due date of the loan. On the contrary, whoever “keeps track” of the three-year limitation period from time when the money was loaned is in the right. At first glance this conclusion is not clear when reading applicable provisions of the Civil Code, but it is in fact rooted in the Supreme Court’s case law of more than 20 years.

Last year the issue re-emerged in a case that reached the Czech Supreme Court. Certain parties entered into a loan agreement under which the loan was to be repaid on the lender’s demand. The lender demanded repayment; however, after almost a year of waiting for the borrower to repay the loan, the lender filed a lawsuit. In the first two instances, the defendant was not successful in claiming that the demand was made three years after the loan was granted (and the debt was established). Both courts ruled that the lawsuit was filed on time since three years had not lapsed from the time when the lender demanded repayment. The defendant was unable to defend his position.

However, the courts were overruled by the Supreme Court, which found their conclusions to be incorrect. The Court reiterated that, when no particular due date is agreed or otherwise determined, the limitation period starts on the day after the debt comes into being. This implies that the lender may even demand the loan to be repaid (and exercise his rights) on the day after it is granted. The day decisive for the beginning of the limitation period is therefore the day following the establishment of the so-agreed legal relationship and not the due date of the loan (the first day after the lender demands repayment).

To justify the opinion that the beginning of the limitation period cannot be coupled with the due date of the loan, the Supreme Court held that, in the given scenario, one could postpone the beginning of the limitation period almost indefinitely.

What the Supreme Court held is not accepted unequivocally. Critics claim that the ruling confuses the lender’s right to have the loan repaid with the lender’s right to demand repayment. In other words, the right to demand is vested in the lender when the loan is made, while the right to have the loan repaid depends on the demand. Each right is subject to an independent three-year limitation period.

One opinion favours legal certainty while the other favours the freedom of lenders. However, before the case law responds to the critics’ opinions, I recommend that the current conservative principle is followed. To avoid any doubt, let me add that the conclusion outlined in this article only applies to obligations and commitments subject to the Civil Code. Commercial obligations and commitments where parties agree to leave the due date to the lender’s discretion are, on the contrary, subject to a limitation period that commences on the due date determined by the lender.

Reklama
Nově na Patria.cz - obchodní signály na forexu podle technických indikátorů ADX, Williams R% a klouzavých průměrů!
Váš názor
Na tomto místě můžete zahájit diskusi. Zatím nebyl zadán žádný názor. Do diskuse mohou přispívat pouze přihlášení uživatelé (Přihlásit). Pokud nemáte účet, na který byste se mohli přihlásit, registrujte se zde.
Aktuální komentáře
23.6.2017
22:02Hlavní indexy na Wall Street jen mírně zpevnily; VIX opět pod 10
18:28Ropa, akcie a výhled příliš hezký na to, aby byl pravdivý
17:46Akciová Praha uzavřela ztrátový týden. Index PX ztratil procento a vzdaluje se hranici 1 000 bodů
17:22Forbes: Nový žebříček 50 nejbohatších Američanů. Každý průměrně vlastní 14,4 miliardy dolarů
17:20Lukáš: Věřím ve stabilizaci ropy, Shell by mohl být dobrou příležitostí (video)
17:14Týden technicky: Euru se tento týden podařilo ubránit pozice na páru s dolarem i korunou
16:46Auditor: 18 z 20 klíčových čínských státních firem nadhodnocovalo tržby
16:41Euro končí týden růstem, koruna stagnací  
16:28Týden na měnách: Nejednotná BoE mává s librou  
15:14Co s boomem v bydlení? Rizika nevidí jen v Česku
13:22Londýnské banky dál přesunují lidi do Evropy, ECB nově chce víc dohledu nad clearingem
12:14Maloja Investment SICAV a.s.: Zveřejňuje Výroční zprávu za období od 1. 8. 2016 – 31. 10. 2016
12:14Proč je cena ropy nejníž od listopadu 2016  
11:17Evropa i na konci týdne mírně v záporu, komoditním titulům se ale daří
11:09Evropa není supermarket, vzkazuje Macron i do Česka
10:52Euro potěšila data, libru další jestřábí komentář  
10:44Růst v eurozóně se po šesti letech dostává na 2 %
9:12Rozbřesk: Boj za vyšší mzdy je v plném proudu
8:48ČEZ dnes obchoduje naposledy s nárokem na dividendu, futures naznačují pokles trhů  
8:21Fed: Americké banky neohrozí ani mimořádně silná recese ekonomiky

Související komentáře
    Nejčtenější zprávy dne
    Nejčtenější zprávy týdne
    Nejdiskutovanější zprávy týdne
    Denní kalendář hlavních událostí
    ČasUdálost
    2:30JP - PMI v průmyslu
    9:30DE - PMI v průmyslu
    10:00EMU - PMI v průmyslu
    16:00USA - Prodeje nových domů