Hledat v komentářích
Investiční doporučení
Výsledky společností - ČR
Výsledky společností - Svět
IPO, M&A
Týdenní přehledy
 

Detail - články
You Are Not a Gadget

You Are Not a Gadget

15.5.2013 7:58

Several media commentators observed recently how quickly the authorities were able to find Tamerlan and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, the two young Chechen brothers who, by Dzhokhar Tsarnaev’s admission, perpetrated the bomb attacks which killed 3 and injured 264 at the Boston Marathon on 15 April. Authorities sifted through thousands of pieces of evidence, including especially a mass of digital photos and video clips, both from official surveillance and those provided by the public and uploaded online. Within two days they have found the suspects and during a massive police operation they hunted them down. The power of technology has demonstrated itself in one of the most poignant ways yet.

Evgeny Morozov, a visiting scholar of Stanford University, writer and researcher, studies political and social implications of technology. Morozov is highly critical of the popular view that the Internet is helping to democratize authoritarian regimes and that technology and social networking are in themselves good for democracy. Instead, he argues that it could also be a powerful tool for engaging in mass surveillance, political repression, and spreading nationalist and extremist propaganda. He says that technology is in fact the perfect tool for repressive states to control their citizens. According to Morozov, the Internet's 'darker' side is the capability for information control and manipulation of new media space. Having been born in Belarussia, he probably knows what he is talking about. Judging by the speed of police action in Boston you may imagine that our own democratic society, dotted by CCTV cameras on every corner, with individual’s personal data displayed online, free to peruse without a warrant, is becoming a Big Brother version of itself, too.

There are numerous examples how technology affects power structures. Merely suspending the internet may be a blunt instrument which backfires. On January 28th 2011 the Mubarak government in Egypt shut down the internet in anticipation of protests. That made activists rush onto the streets, possibly hastening the regime’s end. Controlling the internet can be a far more effective tool. China is very good at it. Other countries are more subtle. Turkey, for instance, constantly adjusts its levels of filtering depending on demands from both the authorities and the general public.

Jaron Zepel Lanier is a pioneer of virtual-reality technology and a Silicon Valley digital-guru. Definitely an insider of the industry, currently working as a Microsoft scholar. He too, however, doesn’t have much good to say about the current state of affairs on the world-wide web. In his famous online essay in 2006 he coined the term Digital Maoism. In his book “You Are Not a Gadget” (2010) he criticized Web 2.0, accusing giants like Facebook and Google of being “spy agencies.

His explanation of the way Google translator works, for instance, is a graphic example of how a giant just takes (or “appropriates without compensation”) and monetizes the work of the crowd. One of the fantastic free services on Google is that you can upload a passage in English to Google Translate and you get back the Czech translation. Most people don’t know how this is done. If pressed, they would probably say there’s some magic artificial intelligence in the cloud, some super clever algorithm that knows how to translate. What a wonderful thing that this is available for free.

In reality, Google has gathered an enormous body of information from real live translators who have translated phrases, and then when your text comes in, Google searches through that data to find similar passages and creates a collage of previous translations. It’s very clever but very much like Facebook, it’s selling people their advertiser-targetable personal identities, buying habits, etc. back to themselves. Google Translate produces a result that is increasingly high quality, available for free and in an instant. In the meantime, the original translators aren’t paid for their work—their work was just appropriated. So by taking value off the books, you’re actually stripping them of the potential income and thus shrinking the economy. The name of the game is ”whoever has the biggest computer can analyze everyone else to their advantage and concentrate wealth and power”.

Lanier is suggesting we are outsourcing ourselves into insignificant advertising-fodder. Jobs in creative professions, such as music and writing, have disappeared, thanks to the ease of communication and copying. More traditional middle-class jobs may be next.

The architecture of Web 2.0 is to blame. While internet was originally open and free, the system has been hijacked by a handful of companies which set up free services—e-mail, social networks, search—and then started to offer them to gullible users in exchange for full access to and ownership of their data. This type of exchange favours the biggest companies which possess an irresistible attraction. While they grow even bigger and soon also rich on the abundance of data collected at nearly zero cost, ordinary people are not paid anything.

As Mr Lanier points out, the industry’s leaders have accumulated great power. For centuries the world has been kept in order by the impulses of religion or the government. Is it technology’s turn now?


Reklama
Nově na Patria.cz - obchodní signály na forexu podle technických indikátorů ADX, Williams R% a klouzavých průměrů!
Váš názor
Na tomto místě můžete zahájit diskusi. Zatím nebyl zadán žádný názor. Do diskuse mohou přispívat pouze přihlášení uživatelé (Přihlásit). Pokud nemáte účet, na který byste se mohli přihlásit, registrujte se zde.
Aktuální komentáře
30.3.2017
17:17ČNB vyškolila i pražskou burzu. "Může" za růst akcií Erste i VIG
17:06Koruna končí období stability, kurz se dostal nejvýš za rok a půl  
16:28Technická analýza: Ceny ropy vstávají z mrtvých
15:20ČEZ: CEZ MH B.V. - Průběžná informace k nabídce na zpětný odkup emise garantovaných vyměnitelných dluhopisů
15:08Ruce si ČNB už uvolnila, korunu zatím ne
15:04Úřady práce v USA registrují výraznější příliv žadatelů o dávky
13:13ČNB ponechává sazby i kurzový závazek. Kdy to bude jinak?
12:22Dražší list papíru. Nová značka H&M má posílit evropské prodeje
12:19Existuje alternativa k americkým akciím?
11:52Daří se ropným titulům, Evropa hledá směr
11:32Investoři se s General Motors perou o hotovost firmy
10:37APS Fund Alpha uzavřený investiční fond, a.s.: Zveřejňuje informaci o konání Valné Hromady dne 28.4.2017
10:24Dolar přehrává euro díky zprávám o měnové politice. Koruna má pro dnešek jasné téma  
9:43Technická analýza: Dolar díky jestřábímu Fedu je zpět u hodnoty 1,0750 EURUSD
9:17Rozbřesk: ČNB nemá důvod otálet s ukončením intervencí
8:59ČEZ, a.s.: CEZ MH B.V. dokončila blokový prodej akcií MOL Hungarian Oil and Gas Plc
8:56Pražskou burzu dnes rozhýbe ČEZ a jeho prodej akcií MOL  
8:44Britský odchod z EU srazil asijské akcie  
8:41ČEZ využívá vysoké ceny akcií MOL a prodává je. Čeká přínos do zisku 3,4 miliardy korun
6:44Nedůvěra k neznámým a vrchol chytrých telefonů v roce 2018

Související komentáře
Nejčtenější zprávy dne
Nejčtenější zprávy týdne
Nejdiskutovanější zprávy týdne
Denní kalendář hlavních událostí
ČasUdálost
13:00CZ - Měnové jednání ČNB, zákl. sazba
14:30USA - HDP, q/q a
14:30USA - Nové žádosti o dávky v nezam.