Hledat v komentářích
Investiční doporučení
Výsledky společností - ČR
Výsledky společností - Svět
IPO, M&A
Týdenní přehledy
 

Detail - články
Deconstructing the Euro

Deconstructing the Euro

26.03.2014 9:19

In January, Chris Williamson, Chief Economist at the economics research firm Markit, called France “the new sick man of Europe.” With near-zero GDP growth, rising unemployment, and mounting public debt – not to mention counter-productive austerity policies – it is difficult to argue otherwise. Given France’s profound importance to Europe’s economic and political stability, this poses a major threat to the entire European project.

Recent developments confirm Williamson’s diagnosis. French business activity sank to a seven-month low in December. While tax revenues increased by €32 billion ($44 billion) last year, the government deficit fell by a mere €8 billion and public debt increased from 89% of GDP to more than 93%. Meanwhile, unemployment rose from 9.5% to 10.5%.

The obvious conclusion is that austerity is not the answer. Indeed, France must abandon its current policies, for its own – and the rest of Europe’s – sake.

France’s problems, like those of the eurozone’s other troubled economies, stem from the fact that the euro’s exchange rate does not align with member countries’ economic positions. As a result, these countries’ virtual exchange rates vis-a-vis Germany are critically overvalued, inasmuch as wages in these countries have risen more quickly, and labor productivity more slowly, than in Germany. Given that the implicit nominal exchange rates are fixed “forever” within the euro, these countries have accumulated major deficits relative to Germany.

Likewise, the deficit countries’ exchange rates are overvalued relative to third countries like the United States and Japan, while Germany’s currency is undervalued, because the euro’s exchange rate is determined by the balance of payments of the eurozone as a whole, which Germany’s massive surplus distorts. In short, the euro exchange rate is too weak for equilibrium in Germany and too strong for equilibrium in France and the other less competitive eurozone economies.

The eurozone’s weaker economies thus face a dilemma: either expand in line with productive potential, thereby incurring external deficits, or enforce austerity, eliminating external deficits by squeezing imports. Under pressure from Germany, they have so far pursued the latter option.

The current “competitive austerity” trend is irrational, first and foremost, because, by undermining domestic demand, it directly controverts the currency union’s fundamental principle that a large domestic market should act as a buffer against external demand shocks. This is causing everyone to suffer – even Germany. Indeed, from 2007 to 2012, Germany’s exports to other eurozone countries declined by 9%, from €432 billion to €393 billion.

But this is not the only threat that austerity poses to Germany’s hard-won prosperity. The euro has also caused Germany’s business cycle to diverge from those of the less competitive economies, while prohibiting customized monetary policies. And the common monetary policy that all are being forced to pursue is intensifying deflationary pressures in the weaker countries, while increasing inflationary pressures in Germany.

Furthermore, populations in the eurozone’s stagnant economies are increasingly demanding that Germany change its policies, increasing wages and implementing measures aimed at boosting consumption and discouraging savings. While responding to such demands would help to ease political tensions across the eurozone, they would face strong opposition within Germany.

Similarly, resolving the crises that will inevitably emerge from the current rigid exchange-rate system will ultimately require Germany to agree either to debt write-offs or to large-scale government-bond purchases by the European Central Bank, which would flood the eurozone with liquidity. Either outcome would run contrary to Germany’s interests and preferences, making it as unfair an approach as austerity.

What the eurozone needs is a solution that does not force any one country or group of countries to bear the brunt of the adjustment – and that means a controlled segmentation of the currency union. Contrary to popular belief, this could be done in a way that reinvigorates the European ideal, rather than reviving the parochial nationalism of the past. The key is to ensure that it arises from the European Union’s economic and political core.

Specifically, Germany, Europe’s greatest economic power, and France, the intellectual progenitor of European unification, should announce their simultaneous exit from the euro and re-adoption of the Deutsche Mark and the franc. This would trigger the immediate revaluation of the Deutsche Mark – and possibly of the franc – relative to the euro.

For their part, other EU member countries would have to decide whether to retain the euro in its truncated form or revert to their own national currencies, possibly pegging them to the revived Deutsche Mark or franc. Regardless of their decision, the price competitiveness of the eurozone’s weaker economies would improve considerably.

Of course, France and Germany would need to implement interim arrangements to safeguard their banking systems’ stability. Moreover, they would have to negotiate with the ECB and other European governments a plan for managing euro-denominated debts.

A period of monetary uncertainty, as European economies adjusted to the new environment, would be unavoidable. But that would be far better than the economic and political impasse in which the eurozone is now trapped.

Joao Ferreira do Amaral was Professor of Economics and Economic Policy at the University of Lisbon and economic adviser to the Portuguese president. Brigitte Granville is Professor of International Economics and Economic Policy and Director of the Center for Globalization Research at Queen Mary, University of London. Hans-Olaf Henkel, former President of the Federation of German Industry, is Professor at the University of Mannheim. Peter Oppenheimer was a fellow at Christ Church, Oxford University. Jean Jacques Rosa is Emeritus Professor of Economics and Finance, Institut d’Etudes Politiques de Paris. Antoni Soy, Professor of Applied Economy, University of Barcelona, was Deputy Minister of Industry and Enterprise in the government of Catalunya. Jean-Pierre Vesperini, Professor of Economics, University of Rouen, was a member of the French Prime Minister’s Council of Economic Analysis.

Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2014.


Váš názor
Na tomto místě můžete zahájit diskusi. Zatím nebyl zadán žádný názor. Do diskuse mohou přispívat pouze přihlášení uživatelé (Přihlásit). Pokud nemáte účet, na který byste se mohli přihlásit, registrujte se zde.
Aktuální komentáře
28.03.2024
9:42Jan Bureš: HDP revidován vzhůru, reálné příjmy domácností rostou a s nimi i útraty
9:31Přehled (ne)obchodování na trzích přes Velikonoce 2024
8:55Se snižováním sazeb v USA není kam spěchat, opakuje guvernér Fedu Waller. Futures jsou zelené  
8:52Putin: Rusko nezaútočí na Pobaltí, Polsko či Česko. Jde jen o strašení lidí
8:45Rozbřesk: HDP potvrdí pozitivní obrat v útratách domácností
6:03Britské akcie jsou nyní (historicky) mimořádně levné a Evropa už obchoduje s výrazným diskontem i vůči Japonsku
27.03.2024
21:19Americké indexy posilovaly díky silnému závěru  
18:26Jen kousek od intervence? Akcie a dluhopisy dnes lehce v zeleném  
17:50Pavol Mokoš: Je čas svézt se na vlně růstu, ne chytat dno. A technické cíle pro pražské banky
15:43BlackRock: Dlouhodobě nebude pokračovat scénář vyšší inflace a sazeb. Postará se o to umělá inteligence a další technologie
15:00ČEZ, a.s.: Zvolen nový místopředseda dozorčí rady ČEZ
13:01FX Výhled: Dolar se připravuje na návrat vyšších sazeb po delší dobu  
11:21Evropa drží pozice po překvapivém americkém poklesu. Spekulace o intervenci na jenu sílí  
11:15BlackRock: Švýcarský monetární signál a další vývoj inflace
10:44Německé hospodářství churaví, shoduje se pět předních ekonomických institutů
9:55Allwyn Financing Czech Republic 2 a.s.: Předběžné neauditované finanční výsledky za rok 2023
9:49Výsledky H&M za první kvartál překonávají odhady. Akcie přidávají 13 pct
9:23Rozbřesk: Březnová inflace v eurozóně ECB nerozhodí
9:07Komerční banka, a.s.: Oznámení o zahájení exkluzivního vyjednávání o prodeji dceřiné společnosti
8:59EP Infrastructure, a.s.: Výsledky skupiny EP Infrastructure za rok 2023

Související komentáře
Nejčtenější zprávy dne
Nejčtenější zprávy týdne
Nejdiskutovanější zprávy týdne
Kalendář událostí
ČasUdálost
Varta AG (12/23 Q4, Bef-mkt)
9:00CZ - HDP, q/q
12:00Walgreens Boots Alliance Inc (02/24 Q2)
13:30USA - HDP, q/q a
13:30USA - Nové žádosti o dávky v nezam.
14:45USA - Index aktivity ISM Chicago
15:00USA - Index spotř. důvěry Mich. university