Hledat v komentářích
Investiční doporučení
Výsledky společností - ČR
Výsledky společností - Svět
IPO, M&A
Týdenní přehledy
 

Detail - články
Is Global Financial Reform Possible?

Is Global Financial Reform Possible?

05.06.2012 7:59

Nowadays there is ample evidence that financial systems, whether in Asia in the 1990’s or a decade later in the United States and Europe, are vulnerable to breakdowns. The cost in interrupted growth and unemployment has been intolerably large.

But, in the absence of international consensus on some key points, reform will be greatly weakened, if not aborted. The freedom of money, financial markets, and people to move – and thus to escape regulation and taxation – might be an acceptable, even constructive, brake on excessive official intervention, but not if a deregulatory race to the bottom prevents adoption of needed ethical and prudential standards.

Perhaps most important is a coherent, consistent approach to dealing with the imminent failure of “systemically important” institutions. Taxpayers and governments alike are tired of bailing out creditors for fear of the destructive contagious effects of failure – even as bailouts encourage excessive risk taking.

By law in the US, new approaches superseding established bankruptcy procedures dictate the demise rather than the rescue of failing firms, whether by sale, merger, or liquidation. But such efforts’ success will depend on complementary approaches elsewhere, most importantly in the United Kingdom and other key financial centers.

Strict uniformity of regulatory practices may not be necessary. For example, the UK and the US may be adopting approaches that differ with respect to protecting commercial banks from more speculative, proprietary trading, but the policy concerns are broadly similar – and may not be so pressing elsewhere, where banking traditions are different and trading is more restrained. But other jurisdictions should not act to undercut the restrictions imposed by home authorities.

Closely related to these reforms is reform of the international monetary system. Indeed, one might legitimately question whether we have a “system” at all, at least compared to the Bretton Woods arrangements and, before that, the seeming simplicity of the gold standard. No one today has been able to exert authority systematically and consistently, and there is no officially sanctified and controlled international currency.

Arguably, the ideal of a well-defined and effective international monetary regime has become more difficult to realize as markets and capital flows have become vastly larger and more capricious. Indeed, the global economy, it is said, has grown – and emerging countries have flourished – without a more organized system.

But what is too often overlooked is that international monetary disorder lay at the root of the successive financial crises of the 1990’s, and played an even more striking role in the crisis that erupted in 2008. The sustained and, in a sense, complementary imbalances in the US and Asia stand out.

From 2000 to 2007, the US ran a cumulative current-account deficit of roughly $5.5 trillion, with nearly symmetrical offsetting increases in reserves in China and Japan. China found it useful to run a large trade surplus, using a very high rate of internal savings and inward foreign investment to support its industrialization and rapid growth.

By contrast, the US, in the face of slow growth, was content to sustain exceptionally high levels of consumption at the expense of personal savings, inflating a massive housing bubble that burst with a very large and deeply disturbing bang.

The practical and inescapable lesson is that when any country is left to its own policy devices, its preferences may lead to prolonged and ultimately unsustainable imbalances. Sooner or later, adjustment will be necessary – if not by considered domestic policy or a well-functioning international monetary system, then by financial crisis.

Not so long ago, we were comforted by theorizing that floating exchange rates would mediate international adjustments in a timely and orderly way. But, in the real world, many countries, particularly but not limited to small, open economies, simply find it impractical or undesirable to permit their currency to float.

We are left with the certainty, however awkward, that active participation in an open world economy requires some surrender of economic sovereignty. Or, to put the point more positively, it requires a willingness to coordinate policies more effectively. The possibilities include:

• Stronger surveillance by the International Monetary Fund and a firmer commitment by countries to abide by “best practices” and agreed norms.

• Direct and public recommendations by the IMF, the G-20, or others, following mandatory consultation.

• Qualification or disqualification with respect to the use of IMF or other credit facilities (for example, central banks’ swap lines).

• Interest or other financial penalties or incentives along the lines under consideration in Europe.

But, if approaches that build on past failure do not seem sufficiently effective, perhaps a new approach toward currency fluctuations would be more promising. That would require some agreement about appropriate “equilibrium” exchange rates, with a fairly wide band that would allow for uncertainty and permit the market to exert its own discipline. But individual countries would orient intervention and economic policies toward defending the equilibrium rate, or, more radically, an international authority might authorize aggressive intervention by trading partners to promote consistency.

An appropriate reserve currency and adequate international liquidity represent another central concern. For years, the pragmatic answer has been the dollar, and to some extent other national currencies, giving rise to complaints of an “inordinate privilege” for the US. But it is not in America’s interest to accentuate and extend its payment deficits at the expense of an internationally competitive economy with strong industry and restrained consumption. And the rest of the world wants the flexibility afforded by the currency of the largest, strongest, and most stable economy.

A useful reserve currency must be limited in supply, but have sufficient elasticity to satisfy the large, unpredictable needs that may arise in a turbulent financial world. Above all, confidence in its stability and availability must be maintained, which highlights the practicality of a national currency, or perhaps a variety of national currencies.

Paul Volcker is a former chairman of the US Federal Reserve Board.

Copyright: Project Syndicate/Fung Global Institute, 2012.


Váš názor
Na tomto místě můžete zahájit diskusi. Zatím nebyl zadán žádný názor. Do diskuse mohou přispívat pouze přihlášení uživatelé (Přihlásit). Pokud nemáte účet, na který byste se mohli přihlásit, registrujte se zde.
Aktuální komentáře
20.09.2021
22:02Krach čínského obra se může přelít do celého světa  
17:57Evergrande a jádro věci
17:32Amerika přebírá štafetu, investoři se dál zbavují akcií, daří se dluhopisům  
16:40Evropské akcie mají prozatím to nejlepší za sebou
15:54Lufthansa prodá nové akcie za 2,14 miliard eur. Chce tak splatit pomoc Německa
14:43Yardeni: Evergrande není Lehman, do Číny neinvestujte, komodity možná za vrcholem
13:36Týdenní výhled: Zabrání opatrný Fed výraznější korekci?  
12:37Dovedu si představit utažení sazeb o 100 bps ještě letos, říká člen rady ČNB Nidetzký
12:25Revoluce na německém akciovém trhu: DAX má deset nových členů i nová pravidla
12:22Rudý start týdne, strach z Číny a přibývající rizika  
12:15Menší dodavatele energií trápí ceny plynu. Britská vláda zvažuje finanční pomoc
10:39Korekce 7 %, příležitosti mimo S&P 500
10:28Špatná vlna akvizic. Technologičtí giganti skupují menší konkurenty
9:32Akcie čínské realitní společnosti Evergrande spadly nejníže od roku 2010
9:14Rozbřesk: Týden o Fedu a německých volbách. Ukončí nebo prohloubí pokles akcií?
8:54Evropské burzy mohou zahájit týden v mínusu  
8:45Schillerová má problém s růstem sazeb ČNB, zdraží státní dluh. Schodek letos kolem 400 miliard korun
6:21Jak může ETF vydělávat víc než podkladové aktivum a další zajímavosti
19.09.2021
15:47Všichni jsou najednou experty na covid. K naší škodě
8:25Víkendář: Co vyžaduje úspěšná transformace firmy

Související komentáře
Nejčtenější zprávy dne
Nejčtenější zprávy týdne
Nejdiskutovanější zprávy týdne
Kalendář událostí
ČasUdálost
Adobe Inc (08/21 Q3, Aft-mkt)
AutoZone Inc (08/21 Q4, Bef-mkt)
FedEx Corp (08/21 Q1, Aft-mkt)
14:00HU - Jednání MNB, základní sazba
14:30USA - Počet nově zahájených staveb